In July this year, it was reported that Lieutenant William Calley Jr, the American soldier convicted of leading and carrying out the My Lai massacre in 1968, had died at the age of 80. He passed away while in hospice care in Florida back in April.
Calley led his soldiers, of Charlie Company, in March 1968 into My Lai village, as part of the American war in Vietnam. Initially informed that there were Viet Cong guerrillas in the area, Calley and his men found none.
Herding the Vietnamese civilians, including women and children, into ditches, the mass killing began. Elderly people were bayoneted, unresisting villagers were herded into huts and firebombed with hand grenades. Women and girls were gang raped. In all, 504 Vietnamese were slaughtered. There were no American casualties.
The massacre was initially covered up by the military authorities. It took the persistent efforts of witnesses, brave US soldiers such as Ron Ridenhour and Hugh Thompson Jr, and a then-young intrepid reporter Seymour Hersh, to bring this horrific massacre to light.
An investigation into the My Lai massacre was launched by the US military, eventually, where witnesses described the atrocities committed in nauseating detail. Calley was the only American soldier convicted of the crime, in 1971. His sentence was subsequently reduced by successive US administrations, and he was placed under house arrest. Charges against every other soldier who participated in the gruesome massacre were dropped.
Sentenced to life imprisonment, Calley was in jail a total of three days, before being placed under house arrest on the orders of then president Richard Nixon. Living on the base where he had been trained, Fort Benning, Georgia, Calley’s sentence was reduced to 10 years in 1974.
Fort Benning, named after a Confederate general, was renamed Fort Moore in 2023.
Calley was pardoned and released in 1975. Numerous pro-war politicians, both Democrat and Republican, waged a political campaign for Calley’s release, claiming that his conviction and sentencing were too harsh. Rehabilitating Calley’s actions was a particular initiative in rehabilitating the American war on Vietnam. The war itself was presented as something noble and righteous, blighted only by the unfortunate actions of overzealous patriotic soldiers like Calley.
Whenever a case like this comes to the attention of the international public, there are demands that international laws and conventions governing the conduct of warring parties be followed. For instance, if American soldiers were captured by the enemy (whether Vietnamese or other nationalities is unimportant) surely Washington would loudly demand that their compatriots be treated with respect and dignity?
There has been a multitude of books and documentary materials relating to the Americans held captive by North Vietnamese forces. Actually, there were no POWs left over after the Vietnam war finished in 1975, but that did not stop Washington from making the mythical POW/MIA an international cause célèbre for decades.
In fact, during World War Two, there was an infamous case of American POWs, after surrendering, were mercilessly gunned down along with cooperating Belgian civilians. The Malmedy massacre, as the incident is known, occurred in December 1944, during the Battle of the Bulge, a major military engagement in Western Europe.
After a brief battle, surrendering American military personnel were killed by the Waffen SS. The German officers responsible for the actual killing, and those who gave the orders to kill POWs, were tried as war criminals in 1946.
Not only were the German soldiers who carried out the killings imprisoned, but also the commanding officers Sepp Dietrich and Joachim Peiper. This was the time of the Cold War, and West Germany formed an indispensable ally in Europe of the Americans. The West German government, though nominally committed to denazification, overlooked the wartime crimes of ex-Nazi officers. The latter infested the armed forces, police and legal apparatus of the West German state.
Dietrich and Peiper, though found guilty of the Malmedy massacre and imprisoned, walked out of gaol free men in the 1950s. These men, and their former Waffen SS colleagues, formed an organisation dedicated to rehabilitating the reputation of Nazi Germany and the wartime SS. American military veterans’ organisations strongly protested the release of Peiper and his associates.
There was a measure of justice in the end. Joachim Peiper lived quietly in France after his release. In 1976, his true identity was discovered – his house was firebombed, and Peiper perished in the flames. His assailants have never been found.
While Calley faced the consequences of his actions, the military and intelligence personnel who designed and rationalised the Vietnam War never faced any accountability. Who among us knows the name Wesley Fishel? A Michigan State University political science professor, he was active in military intelligence and the CIA.
An advisor to the American installed Saigon South Vietnamese regime, he worked closely with Ngo Dinh Diem, Saigon’s American subsidised satrap. Running a vicious dictatorship takes hard work, and Diem was ably assisted by Fishel in this regard. Diem’s secret police, trained and equipped by the United States, formed a feared prop of the Saigon dictatorship.
Fishel designed and advocated the concept of strategic hamlets, forcing Vietnamese villagers into designed camps, demolishing their homes and killing their livestock. The underlying rationale was to deprive the National Liberation Front of recruits. Political loyalties were closely monitored, and the large Buddhist community was targeted by Diem forces.
Fishel himself lived the secluded and luxurious life of a proconsul, keeping his distance from the natives he was supposedly protecting from communism. Indeed, South Vietnam was an American sponsored plutocratic dictatorship, a totalitarian entity that was precisely what they claimed to be fighting against in their communist adversary.
After the war, Fishel returned to the United States, and continued his academic career. His top boss, former Secretary of Defence Robert McNamara, took up the presidency of the World Bank.
It is high time that those who give the orders, seated behind desks and computers, face the consequences for making the decisions which lead directly to heavy loss of life and ecological damage.